There's a Reason Its Called FANFICTION
I was looking through the reviews of some Avatar: The Last Airbender fanfics when I stumbled on one story in particular. It was called "Detours" and it was by a girl named Arekisu. Now, the story wasn't bad, it was just different. However, people these days in the fanfiction world are really starting to dislike anything out-landish and creative. So was said in one girls review of the story, which I thought was a long overdue rant. ^-^
~I would just like to say to all those people who go and bash other peoples stories:
If you don't like the story, why are you reading it? Keep your opinions to yourself! If you have a suggestion, fine, tell your suggestion. If you want to tell them to leave this site forever and stop their desperate attempts, take your own advice! I haven't seen you winning any Newberry awards yet! What is this website called again? Oh, thats right! If I want to hook random characters up with OCs, FINE! Let me do so! If I want to make Sokka and Zuko do a singing duet in Time Square, WHO WILL GIVE A CRAP!? It's their story; let them do what they want! Are you publishing the story? I dont think so! This is online for the writers entertainment, not ours. If you read it, that's up to you! No one wants your mindless attitude on this! Its just a story! Is it happening on the TV show? I dont see any hybrids running around the Fire Nation, so keep the nonsense to yourself. Nobody gives two craps about your fanfiction propaganda; keep that senseless information to yourself. And who gives two craps about the style of writing? Look at the C. S. Lewis: No offence to him, but the man writes like he speaks, yet he's won England's highest mark for childrens literature. And look at the writer of the Roswell novels. She SUCKS beyond borders and yet her book got turned into a TV show! So the next time you go and say this story sucks, tell that to the writers of Avatar. Fanfiction exercises our first amendment and we dont need some neo-yuppy scumbag to tell us that we can't imagine. Any thats what you flamers are lacking: IMAGINATION!! I mean, come on! The stupid insignia for fanfiction tells us to "Unleash our imagination and free our souls". And thats just exactly what these writers are doing. Leave the fanfiction folk alone! Fanfiction was for the psychotic fans who like to invent stuff for the characters, not for the serious writers. If you want serious writing, go pay fifty bucks to read stories on fanstory. com, or whatever the heck that stupid sights called. Learn about karma! One of these days, youre going to get an F on a creative writing assignment because it lacked imagination and grammar and I'm going to be standing right behind you with a bucket of popcorn and laughing my head off while seasoning my popcorn with your tears! You're turning into the neo-yuppies bent on destroying the Christmas spirit from Christmas! You mindless zombie piece of crap. Go stab yourself TWICE! Choke on some paper and die!
Leave us fanfiction folk alone! Go and make fun of the fanstory people! And just so you know where I'm coming from, I know I suck, dont bother reading my story, because I'm sure to have many syntax errors. All this muffling of the creative mind could silence a voice, and when you hear on the news that someone killed themselves after taking the advice of a flame, I hope thats yours!
I hope you choke on a biscotti!
Signed a really irked mediocre writer,
ME.
And if I hear any flames on this, Im sending you a virus.
Email me! I'm ready to take you on in a battle! Shoot, I hope you call and make fun of me! I've been called every name in the book, it won't be new to me! Take your eyes of Arekisu's story and get a life! God, you peopel are stupid and I hope you all die by your own flames! I'd like to see you write your own story! Whoever writes the best one gets the worst recognition! I hate you all worse than my stalker and I have perfect aim on a rifle!~
-halfatheory357
When I read this I felt so happy that somebody else felt the same way I do. I mean, I may not like Mary Sues and dumb plots or OOC fanfics from time to time, but if I don't like it I just won't read it. It's not a fanfic for me, but someone out there will probably like it like no other. Hence, the reason for fanfiction. It's there to satisfy someone's thirst for diversity and creativity. If you just want normal, stick to the story and change nothing type of fanfiction well then what's the point? If it's going to be exactly the same why bother with fanfiction?
Anyways, there's these people outh there who think they're doing people a service by "misting" these fics, which basically means they're making fun of them. No point in it, just mindless comments on how horrible a fic is by making fun of it and expecting the person to take it. These are their reasons to which they justify what they're doing, taken from the sites FAQ ...
~FAQ:
-Who ARE you people?
Booter Freak and Whomever are the co-conspirators of this site. Aside from being a pair of dorks with WAY too much free time, they are ardent lovers of Avatar: The Last Airbender and ardent haters of bad ATLA fanfiction. Hence, the creation of this site---a place where bad ATLA fics can become good humor! If you'd like to contact them, take a lookie-loo at "Contact Us" page.
-What is a MiST?
MiST (aka MST and MST3K), stands for Mystery Science Theater 3000, a show that used to mock terrible movies by having a group of comedians make quips/jokes about it while it played. Sorta like the guys who sit in the back of the movie theater. We do the same thing, only we mock bad fics by interjecting our own commentary.
-Isn’t that kinda like flaming?
Yes and no. Yes in that it’s not helpful to the writer, and mostly is there to make fun of the fic. No in that it’s all meant to be in good humor. Just joking around. We’re not here to earnestly hurt anyone–this is all done in good humor. Unfortunately, not everyone takes it that way.
-YOU GUYS SUCK!!1 HOW DARE YOU INSINUATE THAT MY/MY FRIEND’S FIC IS NOT AKIN TO SLURPING THE SWEET ELIXIR OF LIFE FROM GOD’S MIGHTY, RIGID SHAFT!!!11 *$%# YOU!!!!oneone.
We’re sorry you feel that way. But, please realize: Not everyone will like you/your friend’s fics. If you are too much of an immature wuss that you can’t handle your fic being made fun of, then you have no business posting your fic on public domain, where it can be seen by all.
-You guys are complete bastards. You might not realize it, but your MiSTings hurt authors. Do you know how painful it is to see your fic being made into a laughing stock?
As we said before, if you can’t take the heat, don’t post your fic. Look, in the real world, authors face rejection and ridicule ALL THE TIME. Really, you can’t expect to post your fics on the internet, where it can be seen by everyone, and actually *expect* them ALL to be showered in praise. Especially if what you wrote was crap. Blow your nose and get over it.
-But these writers AREN’T “real authors”! They’re just kids trying to express themselves! Do you want ficcers to stop writing?
WE’RE just kids expressing ourselves too! And anyone who stops writing just because a bunch of nerds with too much time on their hands had fun with their fic should have never started writing in the first place. Get over it.
-I still think you guys are total assholes.
Great. You’re entitled to feel that way. It’s a free domain. Just keep in mind we’re entitled to the option of mocking you and posting it for the world to see.~
My own thoughts: Well, I understand that people have to be prepared to be critized when they post something for everyone to see, but that still doesn't justify this kind of bashing in a "good humor" front. It's not like an actual respectable author is making fun of you (which they never would, they would just give you suggestions on how to improve your writing and to keep trying), instead it's only young kids like yourself who are in the same boat yourself. This seriously makes no sense to me, only that it's meant to either force these poor kids to no longer write or to piss them off so they can make fun of them some more.
I really hope that they stop making fun of fics before things out of control ...
Anyways, I just had to get that off of my chest. I personally think that anyone should be able to write whatever crappy fic they wish to write. And what if you don't like it? Well then don't read it. That's what I've been doing since I was twelve years old and I discovered fanfics (I am currently 16.) I've read from the sickest to the dumbest, to the worst fanfics ever written and I've appreciated every one of them for what they are -- fanfics. Although at times they do leave me asking questions I just decide to stop reading and move on to my own preference of fanfics. Like I said before, someone out there is bound to like that kind of fanfics.
~I would just like to say to all those people who go and bash other peoples stories:
If you don't like the story, why are you reading it? Keep your opinions to yourself! If you have a suggestion, fine, tell your suggestion. If you want to tell them to leave this site forever and stop their desperate attempts, take your own advice! I haven't seen you winning any Newberry awards yet! What is this website called again? Oh, thats right! If I want to hook random characters up with OCs, FINE! Let me do so! If I want to make Sokka and Zuko do a singing duet in Time Square, WHO WILL GIVE A CRAP!? It's their story; let them do what they want! Are you publishing the story? I dont think so! This is online for the writers entertainment, not ours. If you read it, that's up to you! No one wants your mindless attitude on this! Its just a story! Is it happening on the TV show? I dont see any hybrids running around the Fire Nation, so keep the nonsense to yourself. Nobody gives two craps about your fanfiction propaganda; keep that senseless information to yourself. And who gives two craps about the style of writing? Look at the C. S. Lewis: No offence to him, but the man writes like he speaks, yet he's won England's highest mark for childrens literature. And look at the writer of the Roswell novels. She SUCKS beyond borders and yet her book got turned into a TV show! So the next time you go and say this story sucks, tell that to the writers of Avatar. Fanfiction exercises our first amendment and we dont need some neo-yuppy scumbag to tell us that we can't imagine. Any thats what you flamers are lacking: IMAGINATION!! I mean, come on! The stupid insignia for fanfiction tells us to "Unleash our imagination and free our souls". And thats just exactly what these writers are doing. Leave the fanfiction folk alone! Fanfiction was for the psychotic fans who like to invent stuff for the characters, not for the serious writers. If you want serious writing, go pay fifty bucks to read stories on fanstory. com, or whatever the heck that stupid sights called. Learn about karma! One of these days, youre going to get an F on a creative writing assignment because it lacked imagination and grammar and I'm going to be standing right behind you with a bucket of popcorn and laughing my head off while seasoning my popcorn with your tears! You're turning into the neo-yuppies bent on destroying the Christmas spirit from Christmas! You mindless zombie piece of crap. Go stab yourself TWICE! Choke on some paper and die!
Leave us fanfiction folk alone! Go and make fun of the fanstory people! And just so you know where I'm coming from, I know I suck, dont bother reading my story, because I'm sure to have many syntax errors. All this muffling of the creative mind could silence a voice, and when you hear on the news that someone killed themselves after taking the advice of a flame, I hope thats yours!
I hope you choke on a biscotti!
Signed a really irked mediocre writer,
ME.
And if I hear any flames on this, Im sending you a virus.
Email me! I'm ready to take you on in a battle! Shoot, I hope you call and make fun of me! I've been called every name in the book, it won't be new to me! Take your eyes of Arekisu's story and get a life! God, you peopel are stupid and I hope you all die by your own flames! I'd like to see you write your own story! Whoever writes the best one gets the worst recognition! I hate you all worse than my stalker and I have perfect aim on a rifle!~
-halfatheory357
When I read this I felt so happy that somebody else felt the same way I do. I mean, I may not like Mary Sues and dumb plots or OOC fanfics from time to time, but if I don't like it I just won't read it. It's not a fanfic for me, but someone out there will probably like it like no other. Hence, the reason for fanfiction. It's there to satisfy someone's thirst for diversity and creativity. If you just want normal, stick to the story and change nothing type of fanfiction well then what's the point? If it's going to be exactly the same why bother with fanfiction?
Anyways, there's these people outh there who think they're doing people a service by "misting" these fics, which basically means they're making fun of them. No point in it, just mindless comments on how horrible a fic is by making fun of it and expecting the person to take it. These are their reasons to which they justify what they're doing, taken from the sites FAQ ...
~FAQ:
-Who ARE you people?
Booter Freak and Whomever are the co-conspirators of this site. Aside from being a pair of dorks with WAY too much free time, they are ardent lovers of Avatar: The Last Airbender and ardent haters of bad ATLA fanfiction. Hence, the creation of this site---a place where bad ATLA fics can become good humor! If you'd like to contact them, take a lookie-loo at "Contact Us" page.
-What is a MiST?
MiST (aka MST and MST3K), stands for Mystery Science Theater 3000, a show that used to mock terrible movies by having a group of comedians make quips/jokes about it while it played. Sorta like the guys who sit in the back of the movie theater. We do the same thing, only we mock bad fics by interjecting our own commentary.
-Isn’t that kinda like flaming?
Yes and no. Yes in that it’s not helpful to the writer, and mostly is there to make fun of the fic. No in that it’s all meant to be in good humor. Just joking around. We’re not here to earnestly hurt anyone–this is all done in good humor. Unfortunately, not everyone takes it that way.
-YOU GUYS SUCK!!1 HOW DARE YOU INSINUATE THAT MY/MY FRIEND’S FIC IS NOT AKIN TO SLURPING THE SWEET ELIXIR OF LIFE FROM GOD’S MIGHTY, RIGID SHAFT!!!11 *$%# YOU!!!!oneone.
We’re sorry you feel that way. But, please realize: Not everyone will like you/your friend’s fics. If you are too much of an immature wuss that you can’t handle your fic being made fun of, then you have no business posting your fic on public domain, where it can be seen by all.
-You guys are complete bastards. You might not realize it, but your MiSTings hurt authors. Do you know how painful it is to see your fic being made into a laughing stock?
As we said before, if you can’t take the heat, don’t post your fic. Look, in the real world, authors face rejection and ridicule ALL THE TIME. Really, you can’t expect to post your fics on the internet, where it can be seen by everyone, and actually *expect* them ALL to be showered in praise. Especially if what you wrote was crap. Blow your nose and get over it.
-But these writers AREN’T “real authors”! They’re just kids trying to express themselves! Do you want ficcers to stop writing?
WE’RE just kids expressing ourselves too! And anyone who stops writing just because a bunch of nerds with too much time on their hands had fun with their fic should have never started writing in the first place. Get over it.
-I still think you guys are total assholes.
Great. You’re entitled to feel that way. It’s a free domain. Just keep in mind we’re entitled to the option of mocking you and posting it for the world to see.~
My own thoughts: Well, I understand that people have to be prepared to be critized when they post something for everyone to see, but that still doesn't justify this kind of bashing in a "good humor" front. It's not like an actual respectable author is making fun of you (which they never would, they would just give you suggestions on how to improve your writing and to keep trying), instead it's only young kids like yourself who are in the same boat yourself. This seriously makes no sense to me, only that it's meant to either force these poor kids to no longer write or to piss them off so they can make fun of them some more.
I really hope that they stop making fun of fics before things out of control ...
Anyways, I just had to get that off of my chest. I personally think that anyone should be able to write whatever crappy fic they wish to write. And what if you don't like it? Well then don't read it. That's what I've been doing since I was twelve years old and I discovered fanfics (I am currently 16.) I've read from the sickest to the dumbest, to the worst fanfics ever written and I've appreciated every one of them for what they are -- fanfics. Although at times they do leave me asking questions I just decide to stop reading and move on to my own preference of fanfics. Like I said before, someone out there is bound to like that kind of fanfics.

As for telling them, I have tried with other people (amazing how much they despise bad fanfics) and I will continue to try. Even if people critize my own fics because of it. I know I'm not a great writer and I know my spelling and grammar stinks but I am trying to improve through writing fanfics.
Well, if you are concerned about your spelling and grammar (which, from what I've seen, seems fine to me!), I'm a beta reader and am always willing to read and edit stories. So if you ever want some advice before you post something, let me know! A second pair of eyes is always helpful. ^_^
You'd be my beta-reader? Really? Awesome, I've never had one before and I think I really need one. ^_^ However, I don't know when my next update of a fic will be ... I am extremely slow when it comes to updates. But, I appreciate the offer and will take you up on it when I finish updating a fic of mine. ^-^
Anyways, thanks again. ^-^
I just want to point out that Arekisu gave permission for the Misting.
http://www.freewebs.com/avatard_the_las
((Note: A word of HUGE THANKS to Arekisu for being so cool and awesome as to allow us to MiST her fic. A lot of the younger writers could learn something from her resiliance and general good-naturedness. Our hats are off to you, Arekisu!))
There are some ficwriters who don't mind intensive critiques. I actually ask my writing buddies to be brutal in their critiques. I prefer such to be done in private though because I don't want them to get into trouble.
An intensive critique and an outright mockery are two totally different things.
I would have preferred an intensive critique... ;_;MIST is a mocking type of intensive critique.
But thank you for leaving me the comment, it was very helpful and I appreciate it. ^_^
I just wanted to say that
It was upsetting, sure (if you go to the YWABFI section, I was made into an example of how NOT to write fanfiction, which was even more depressing). But it also helped me realize that my fanfic sucked and helped me move on to original fiction, which is SO much better.
Why be bound by the laws of canon? With original fiction, nobody can walk in and say, "Your character is a Mary Sue! Go to Hell! Your characters are OOC!" (Which, yeah, is what I was told.)
Not to mention that I'm actually now friends with the creator of the MiSTing site, who is a good person and feels bad about the whole thing.
Getting to the point here, sorry. ^^; If I'd read this post a few months ago I would have worshipped you for the fact that somebody actually agreed with me and understood where I was coming from, but now it doesn't seem like such a big deal.
So I'm glad I got that off your chest, and I wish that everyone had your "It's just fanfiction, if I don't like it I won't read it" attitude. There would be a lot less flamers...
However, my only concern with this is that if it forces the young writers to give up on writing, which I hope it doesn't. I think they should be allowed to write whatever is on their minds and not be made of for it. The oddest fanfics can sometimes be the greatest fanfics.
Anyways, I really appreciate that you posted and cleared all of that up. Thank you. And I hope it's going well for you in original fiction, I know I've been contemplating writing some myself. It seems like you'd have more freedom to write. And yes, no more people telling you your character is a Mary Sue!! XD I honestly don't understand why people hate Mary Sues so much though ...
Well, once again thank you and I hope you're doing well!! ^_^